HVAC & Plumbing6 min read

Tankless vs. Tank Water Heater: Cost, Efficiency & Flow

By SpanSizer Editorial Team
• Updated

Need Exact Math for Your Project?

Launch our free online tool: Tankless Water Heater Size Calculator

Open Calculator

Tankless vs. Tank Water Heater — Assembly Anatomy

Interactive 3D Isometric Engineering Rig • Verified Model

Interactive Model
Interactive Spec Explorer:
sand = 1" (ICPI OK)
60mm Interlocking Pavers & Polymeric Joints1" ASTM C33 Washed Concrete Sand Bed (1")6" Compacted #57 Stone BaseASTM D4632 Geotextile Stabilization FabricEngineered interlocking paver assembly adhering to ICPI Tech Spec 2. Illustrates depth-ordered cross-section: compacted crushed aggregate sub-base, non-woven separation fabric, exactly 1 inch of uncompacted ASTM C33 washed concrete sand, interlocking concrete pavers, and spiked commercial edge restraint.

A tankless water heater heats water only when you turn on a tap, so it never runs out and doesn't lose heat from a stored tank. The trade-offs are a higher installed price, about $2,400 to $3,800 for a gas unit in our calculator, and a limit on how much hot water it can deliver at once. A tank heater is simpler and cheaper to install but can run out during long showers and loses some heat while it sits.

Executive Summary & Field Takeaway

TL;DR

- Tankless: endless hot water, no standby loss, but a flow-rate limit; about $2,400–$3,800 installed (gas).

- Tank: lower upfront cost and simpler install, but a fixed amount of hot water and standby heat loss.

- Efficiency: ENERGY STAR's minimum rating is higher for gas tankless (UEF 0.95) than for gas tanks (UEF 0.81–0.86).

- Sizing tankless: add up the hot water you use at once; two showers and a sink in a cold climate need about 5.5 GPM.

- Best fit: tankless suits homes that want endless hot water and have room for a bigger gas line or electric service.

Side-by-side comparison

TanklessTank
Hot water supplyContinuous, up to its flow rateLimited to the tank, then a recovery wait
Standby heat lossNoneSome heat lost while water sits
Installed cost (gas)About $2,400–$3,800 in our calculatorUsually lower; get local quotes
Upgrades often neededLarger gas line, new venting, or large electric serviceUsually fits the existing setup
SpaceWall-mounted, compactFloor tank
ENERGY STAR minimum efficiency (gas)UEF 0.95UEF 0.81–0.86

The efficiency figures are the minimum ratings for ENERGY STAR certification, from ENERGY STAR's water heater criteria. A higher UEF means a more efficient heater. How much you actually save depends on how much hot water your household uses.

The flow-rate limit

A tankless heater has to heat water as fast as it flows. Its capacity is measured in gallons per minute (GPM) at a given temperature rise, and high-efficiency gas units typically deliver about 2 to 5 GPM. The colder your incoming water, the less flow the same unit can deliver.

Our tankless water heater size calculator counts 2.0 GPM per shower and 1.5 GPM per other fixture:

HouseholdPeak flowIncoming waterTemperature riseGas input needed
1 shower2.0 GPM50°F70°Fabout 82,000 BTU
2 showers + 1 fixture5.5 GPM42°F78°Fabout 252,000 BTU
3 showers + 1 fixture7.5 GPM65°F55°Fabout 243,000 BTU

A large household in a cold region can need more than one unit, or should stagger showers and the dishwasher.

Electric tankless

Electric tankless heaters need very large circuits. Our calculator shows the two-shower, cold-climate home above would need about 105 kW, beyond what many homes' electrical service can supply. Electric tankless works best for one bathroom or as a point-of-use heater under a sink.

Which should you choose?

  • Choose tankless if you run out of hot water now, want to free up floor space, and your home can handle the gas line, venting or electrical upgrade.
  • Choose a tank if you want the lowest upfront cost, your current setup works, or your hot water use is modest and fairly spread out.
  • Get the install price in writing either way: for tankless, the gas line, venting and any electrical work can move the total a lot.

FAQ

Do tankless water heaters really never run out?

They don't run out as long as you stay within their flow rate. If more fixtures run at once than the unit can heat, the water gets cooler instead.

Is a tankless water heater worth it for a family of four?

It can be, if it's sized for the showers that run at the same time and your gas line can supply it. Use the sizing calculator to see the flow rate and burner size your home needs.

How much does a tankless water heater cost installed?

Our calculator estimates about $2,400–$3,800 installed for a condensing gas unit, or $1,100–$1,600 for the unit and parts alone. Gas line and venting work add to that.

Do tankless water heaters need maintenance?

Most manufacturers recommend periodic flushing to remove scale, especially with hard water. Check the manual for the interval.

Sources

Free · No obligation

Rather hire it out? Compare local HVAC quotes

Tell us about your project and we'll share it with up to 3 contractors who serve your ZIP code. Always ask for proof of license and insurance before you hire.

Up to 3 local quotesFree for homeownersNo obligation to hire
How we build these guides

Quantities come from the same formulas as our calculators, and prices come from the sources listed in each guide. Read how SpanSizer works.