Metal Roof vs. Shingles: Cost, Lifespan & Which Is Worth It
Need Exact Math for Your Project?
Launch our free online tool: Metal Roof Calculator
Metal Roof vs. Shingles — Assembly Anatomy
Interactive 3D Isometric Engineering Rig • Verified Model
A standing seam metal roof costs about twice as much as architectural shingles upfront: on a 50 × 30 ft ranch with a 5/12 roof, our calculators put metal at about $15,750–$24,000 and shingles at $8,223–$12,155. Metal lasts much longer, though: This Old House, citing InterNACHI, puts architectural shingles at about 30 years and metal at 40–80 years. Whether metal pays off depends mostly on how long you'll stay in the house.
TL;DR
- Installed cost, 1,500 sq ft ranch: metal $15,750–$24,000; architectural shingles $8,223–$12,155.
- Lifespan: architectural shingles about 30 years, three-tab about 20, metal 40–80 years.
- Cost per year of life: shingles about $274–$405; metal about $197–$600, depending on how long it lasts.
- Metal wins if you'll stay long enough to skip a reroof; shingles win on upfront cost and easy repairs.
- Climate, ventilation and installation quality change real lifespan for both.
Cost on the same house
We priced a 50 × 30 ft ranch house with a 5/12 gable roof both ways:
| Roof | What it takes | Installed cost |
|---|---|---|
| Architectural shingles | 17.88 squares, 54 bundles | $8,223 – $12,155 |
| Standing seam metal | 2 roof planes, 38 panels each (16-inch seams) | $15,750 – $24,000 |
The shingle price comes from our shingle calculator. The metal price is two runs of our metal roof calculator, one for each 50 ft × 15 ft side of the roof (derived: 2 × $7,875 and 2 × $12,000). Both include materials and labor; tear-off of the old roof and decking repairs are extra.
How long each roof lasts
| Roof | Typical lifespan |
|---|---|
| Three-tab asphalt shingles | about 20 years |
| Architectural asphalt shingles | about 30 years |
| Metal | 40–80 years |
These figures come from This Old House, which cites InterNACHI's life expectancy chart. Real lifespan depends on climate (heat, sun and coastal salt all shorten it), attic ventilation, roof slope, installation quality and maintenance.
Cost per year of life
Dividing the installed price by the lifespan (derived):
| Roof | Cost | Lifespan | Cost per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural shingles | $8,223 – $12,155 | 30 years | about $274 – $405 |
| Metal, if it lasts 40 years | $15,750 – $24,000 | 40 years | about $394 – $600 |
| Metal, if it lasts 80 years | $15,750 – $24,000 | 80 years | about $197 – $300 |
The ranges overlap. Metal only comes out ahead per year if it reaches the longer end of its lifespan, and you only collect that benefit if you own the house long enough. If you plan to sell within 10–15 years, shingles usually make more financial sense.
Other differences
- Repairs: a damaged shingle can be replaced cheaply; metal panel repairs need the right panel profile and a roofer who works with metal.
- Weather: metal sheds snow readily, and standing seam has no exposed fasteners on the panels. Shingles are rated for wind and hail by class; check the rating for your area.
- Noise: with solid decking and underlayment, rain on a metal roof is usually less noticeable than people expect.
- Looks and resale: metal suits modern and farmhouse styles; shingles fit almost any house and are what most buyers expect.
FAQ
Is a metal roof worth the extra cost?
It can be if you'll stay long enough for its longer life to matter. On our example ranch, metal costs roughly $7,500–$11,800 more upfront (derived: $15,750 − $8,223 and $24,000 − $12,155), which pays back only if it saves you a future reroof.
How much does a metal roof cost per square?
On our example, about $970–$1,480 per square of roof surface (derived: $15,750 and $24,000 over about 16.25 squares of sloped area). Shingles come to about $460–$680 per square.
Can you put a metal roof over shingles?
Some metal systems can go over one layer of shingles where local code allows, but many roofers prefer a tear-off so they can check the decking. Ask your roofer and building department.
How long do architectural shingles last?
About 30 years, according to the InterNACHI figures cited by This Old House, with climate, ventilation and installation quality making a big difference.
Sources
- This Old House – How Long Does a Roof Last? (lifespans citing InterNACHI)
- SpanSizer shingle calculator and metal roof calculator (prices for the example ranch)
Rather hire it out? Compare local roofing quotes
Tell us about your project and we'll share it with up to 3 contractors who serve your ZIP code. Always ask for proof of license and insurance before you hire.
Quantities come from the same formulas as our calculators, and prices come from the sources listed in each guide. Read how SpanSizer works.